The substantia nigra pars reticulata (SNr) functions as the principal inhibitory output of the basal ganglia, with the timing of its spikes critically controlling downstream disinhibition required for movement initiation. The external globus pallidus (GPe) and D1-expressing medium spiny neurons (D1-MSNs) in the striatum provide GABAergic inputs to the SNr that differ in their amplitude and kinetic properties. How these inputs interact with the intrinsic membrane currents that determine SNr firing is only partially understood. Using optogenetics, computational modeling, and electrophysiology in acute mouse brain slices, 47 animals of either sex were used for measurements, and we found an unexpected interaction between GABAergic inputs and hyperpolarization-activated currents (Ih) that tunes inhibitory efficacy in a pathway-specific manner. GPe inputs evoke fast, large IPSCs that transiently suppress SNr firing within a narrow window but whose rapid decay enables depolarization from Ih to restore firing after only a brief pause. In contrast, the slower decay kinetics of striatal IPSCs enables more sustained inhibition that counters the depolarizing drive from Ih to produce longer pauses, despite their lower conductance amplitudes. Pharmacological blockade of Ih with ZD7288 eliminated the rapid recovery of firing after GPe inhibition and equalized the inhibitory efficacy between GPe and striatal pathways. These findings establish an important interplay between synaptic kinetics and intrinsic membrane conductances in establishing pathway-specific inhibitory balance in the basal ganglia. Our study reveals that inhibitory pathways to the substantia nigra pars reticulata are differentially shaped by the interplay between synaptic kinetics and intrinsic membrane conductances. Using optogenetics, electrophysiology, and modeling, we showed that fast-decaying GABAergic inputs from the external globus pallidus are rapidly overcome by Ih, producing only brief pauses in SNr firing, whereas slower striatal inputs generate longer-lasting inhibition. Blocking Ih abolishes this difference, demonstrating that intrinsic currents tune inhibitory efficacy in a pathway-specific manner. These results identify a biophysical mechanism that helps set the balance of basal ganglia output essential for movement control.